Our reading had a lot about reduction which I
found fascinating, but I got drawn to the section on electronic reuse. With the whole fuss about the new iPhone 5 coming out, and people camping in line, and acting like nut cases for a little hand held gadget that quite frankly doesn't do much more than the iPhone 4 really, strikes me as interest.
A cellphone doesn't go "bad" it just goes out of style. So what are you going to do with your iPhone 4 now, since you have been tirelessly waiting in line for the epic release of the iPhone 5? Are you going to chuck it in the trash, or just leave it in an empty drawer? WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO? And you better not say trash it or disassemble it!
I wanted to find out how eco friendly the new iPhone 5 is since Apple has a mission to be as green as much as they can. In their reports they claim that the new iPhone 5 and the iPhone 4 both are mercury, arsenic, BFR, and PVC free which is great because those were what was causing dioxins. But lets take notice to the follow:
![]() |
Click on the image for the full iPhone 4S report from Apple |
![]() |
Click on the image for the full iPhone 5 report from Apple |
Did you notice a 20 kg CO2e spike from the iPhone 4S to the iPhone 5! That is roughly the weight of an average 4 year old! WOW Apple... really sounds like you are committed to being green.
So I obviously started googling to find a way to reuse or recycle an old iPhone because let's be honest that is a lot of CO2e.
So what are some of your reusing options you ask?
1. Re-Sell your iPhone on eBay
... and make some $ back for the ridiculous amount you spent on this one2. Turn your cell into a Remote using a simple app.
Yup, it is really easy and since you most likely have a bunch of Apple products it will work for your iTunes and Apple TV so you don't have to buy one. Other apps will give your more expandable functions as well.3. Don't buy a Kindle... Just download the app... it's even FREE!
You won't need to spend more on an iPad or a Kindle when you can download it for free and use just your old iPhone exclusively as your new E-Reader. It is even more convenient because it is smaller.4. Turn it into your fancy new alarm clock using just a dock (which you probably already own anyways)
Why wake up to a screaming buzzer when you can wake up to some sweet tunes. Your old iPhone already has your 10,000 song library on it, so wake up to a new song every day and use it exclusively as your alarm clock.
But if none of these are your cup of tea, and you prefer to drink the Koolaid then you can always
5. Recycle it with Apple.
They offer a buyback program in concordance with PowerON where they estimate the value of your phone, you ship it in, and then receive a gift card to spend on Apple retail. So, not too bad of a trade off if you were going to get rid of your phone anyways; I guess you could always spend the gift card on a new adapter you are going to need since all of your accessories aren't going to work on your new iPhone 5. But hey, you recycled and that was on the of things that Captain Planet taught your right? Or was that your Kindergarten teacher?
Either way, no matter whether you traded your phone in, are still reusing it, or someone else is, it isn't leaking dioxins into the environment. Which was the main point I wanted to get across here. Capitalism, though necessary for our economy, and part of the American culture, doesn't need to be environmentally unfriendly. Sending your stuff back to Apple is kind of a great idea. It is going to get reused in another new i*insert another totally cool thing, like CAR here* and help me sleep a little better at night. With natural resources depleting, and everyone having excess things they don't even use there is no reason why we shouldn't Reduce, Reuse, and yes I am saying it Recycle.
So way to do your part Apple... Well kind of... but not really.
What can I say, I am still a Capitalistic American... But hey I still care!
P.S. I don't own an iPhone, I bought a used HTC on eBay and gave my old one to a friend who broke theirs! So see. It is really possible.
P.P.S. I feel totally accomplished right now because I did all the aforementioned phone jazz without even realizing I was recycling and reusing!
-Stephanie
Last Christmas, Joe & I started really thinking about this. We got some Christmas money & were excited about getting a new TV. We found a repackaged one that was $80 cheaper. Awesome. We got it home & found a smear on the screen, but we were able to scrub it off. We know it was returned after Christmas; a family thought it was ruined. We saved money & packaging... which led us to a whole world of buying used. I mean, we're used book addicts, but now between the money & packaging savings, why would we buy new? What's great about it is that most stores have repackaged, refurbished or used goods--from Game Stop (for Joe) & Target (for me).
ReplyDeleteI agree with your post, and I wasn't surprised to see that the iPhone 5 is produced with more emissions. Earlier this summer, Apple decided not to register its products with EPEAT, (Electronic Product Environmental Assessment Tool) which reports the environmental impacts of various electronic products. This tool is used by the STARS campus sustainability tool to evaluate how environmentally friendly electronic devices are on a particular campus. It was only after negative feedback from customers that the company backtracked, and decided not to withdraw from EPEAT.
ReplyDeletehttp://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/07/13/apple-backtracks-on-withdrawal-from-environmental-ratings/
Your post reminds me of a manifesto issued by self-repair website ifixit about two years ago, largely targeted at Apple. That company (and others) intentionally makes their products difficult/impossible to repair ourselves. The manifesto states repair is better than recycling, and that it saves the planet. And they call BS on these companies' green claims.
ReplyDeleteCheck it out: http://www.ifixit.com/blog/2010/11/09/self-repair-manifesto/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed:ifixit/blogiFixitBlog&utm_content=GoogleReader
And, if you ever need help fixing electronics (including an iphone) this site is fantastic.
I do not have an iphone and the only apple product I own is an ipod classic I bought 6 years. But this made me think, we make such a big deal about Apple's products and now how Jeff mentioned are not registered with EPEAT (Electronic Product Environmental Assessment Tool). But what about all those other phones out there! There are others! I have a almost 2 year old Motorola Driod Pro. And according to their website "Cell phones have about a two-year lifetime. As a result, their use phase is responsible for relatively little of their (CO2) footprint, while the manufacturing phase accounts for about 90 percent." Well my phone is soon about to reach the end of its lifetime. And when its usable life is over I am just going to take it back with their Recycling and Take Back Program.
ReplyDeletehttps://communities.motorola.com/community/fresh_ideas/blog/tags/sustainability
While in part I do agree that this craziness preceding the release of the iPhone 5 is a little ridiculous, I think that the big underlying problem here is that we have grown such a intoxicating dependence on material things. Because I mean really, the people who are sitting outside a Best Buy waiting for an iPhone, are just symbolic of any other consumer, excited about getting the latest and the greatest of anything. Take Black Friday for example. Someone was actually killed, trampled over, near my hometown a few years ago when customers stampeded into a Wall-Mart , unable to control themselves searching for holiday deals on STUFF.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/29/business/29walmart.html?pagewanted=all
That for me puts it into a pretty good perspective of where our society needs to make a change. Its not just Apple, or the corporations, the change needs to happen from the people as well.
I've come to realize I'm a very 'bad' American. I still own a dumb phone, I don't have a tablet, I broke down and bought my first laptop ever this summer for Grad School, and even my Ipod is probably almost a decade old by now. I cannot say the same for my family, though beside the two year phone cycle I wouldn't say they're too bad on the normal 'must buy the newest shiny thing to come out' typical mindset.
ReplyDeleteOn that point I have become rather disgusted at the people I have class with fawning so insanely over the new Iphone. I admit to knowing almost nothing about the Iphone, since I see no use in a smart phone even for as much of a geek as I am, but it looks worse than the Iphone 4 if you ask me.
The whole two year phone cycle was as logical as it could be when the technology was jumping in leaps and bounds a decade ago. But now the 'newest features' are a fractional slimming down and a wider screen? I mean is it really that much faster, or rather does your PHONE need to load Angry Birds half a second faster?
Sure the iphone has cool apps and what not, but is it really worth it? From a practical standpoint, the amount of money people are paying for the upgrade when none of the accessories from the previous models are compatible seems a bit silly. And that's not even taking into consideration the environmental impacts.
ReplyDeleteThat's one of the biggest problems with consumerism- the lack of thought that goes into the environmental impact a product is causing. I'm guilty of it too- it wasn't until the past few years that I began think about where the products I purchased came from, and what type of effects making/shipping it took on the environment.
It's not as though the people purchasing the iphone (or other environmentally unfriendly products) don't care about the environment either. It's just that considering if your cell phone is environmentally friendly is not part of the typical American's thought process. This takes me back to previous readings we have had for this class that have made me question, how do we change the mindset of the everyday American? How do we make considering the environmental impacts of a product part of their thought processes?
Yes, I am one of the horrible people that purchased an iPhone 5. My only defense is that I had no other phone (I had been borrowing one from a friend since I lost mine in Europe). I know that purchasing a used phone is definitely a greener way to go, but as far as buying a new cell phone, is Apple really worse than the competitors? As far as I know, Verizon (my provider) doesn't carry any "green" phones. Treehugger.com makes an argument for iphone's being a eco-friendly choice, but it really applies to any smartphone. http://www.treehugger.com/gadgets/most-eco-friendly-cell-phones-market.html
ReplyDeleteStephanie, you are quiet the poet. Thanks for a fun and reflective read. And very timely. There is a lot of discussion re: cradle to cradle when it comes to anything with a battery (especially hybrid car batteries at end of life, and how 'green' they actually are when the batteries produce a whole lot of waste). However, I hadn't considered the emissions for production. We know all about the human rights issues associated with the over worked employees that assemble our life lines (iPhones, yes, I have one and an ipad and I don't know what I did with out them) but not the emissions. However, this summer San Fran City Govt. made fairly publicly just how "not green" they think Apple is: the city took Apple Products off of it's EPEAT list and therefore, will no longer purchase Apple products for government use. http://www.valuewalk.com/2012/07/san-francisco-government-to-ban-apple-products-for-its-officials/. It's unclear how effective this will be or what it really means, but it was a fairly public event over the summer.
ReplyDeleteOn reuse -- I shared this article on twitter earlier this month, but want to share it with you because it's one of my favorites from HuffPo Impact and other re-uses for your old iPhones: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/12/iphone-5-donate-old-phone_n_1878402.html.